By Dr. Satish Asotra
•
12 Dec, 2023
All human beings experience unpleasant experiences on a regular basis, and some on a daily basis. We may have to deal with tension and unprecedented events during all stages and ages of our lives due to different or similar causes of triggers. Some professions face challenges more frequently than others. Repeated exposure to stressors can profoundly affect the mind, general health, and quality of life. Personnel working in various services are often confronted with a range of unique challenges and situations, which might hamper their bodily health and psychological well-being. History of PTSD Awareness The PTSD condition was identified and diagnosed in the Western medicine after the Vietnam war. However, PTSD’s effects were downplayed at that time due to the stigma surrounding mental health ailments. It was described as only battle fatigue or shell shock. It was a former misunderstanding that only the weak-willed soldiers suffered from PTSD. Diagnostic improvements and studies of Post-Vietnam syndrome afterward resulted in a broader comprehension of the link between traumatic events and long-term emotional outcomes. The individual experiences were so bad that the veterans were open to try anything. A few Veterans had no strong preference for one type of treatment or another, instead expressing that they were willing to give any treatment option a try so that they get back a normal mental health. PTSD Facts PTSD is an anxiety disorder that a person may experience after a traumatic event or series of events, like a death of a loved one, assault, abuse, car crash, a natural disaster, war, extreme emotional shock, or childhood neglect. PTSD is manifested by unwanted memories of the event, avoidance behaviours, over stress, over work and continuous emotional stress similar to healthcare workers experienced providing care to COVID patients as well as general public that suffered during recent pandemic experience. Long-term, chronic trauma can affect a person’s ability to behave normally and experience unhealthy daily life, difficulty in trusting relationships and even daily functions of life. Other contributors to development of PTSD would also include: Recurring, distressing events experienced in relationships or at work- normal working environment in offices/corporations/ retail work environment, etc. Operational stress injuries (OSIs) from frontline work- firefighters, police officers, emergency responders, unhealthy work environment. Among many mental challenges, the personnel in uniforms face, post-traumatic anxiety disorder (PTSD) is common and can be debilitating. As part of experience faced by personnel during deployment (prevalent for military personnel) witness traumatic events, life-threatening circumstances, acts of violence and, atrocities challenge their fundamental beliefs about the world and humanity. Moral injuries from participating in or witnessing acts that go against your beliefs- violence related to incompatibilities, e.g., wars, religious confrontations, inequality at work/ office environment places etc. Different challenges to an individual’s own situation occur and may be exacerbated by a cumulative or a single mental challenge/injury that may precipitate a PTSD situation. Such mental challenges have been identified thousands of years ago in Ayurveda medicine practice and in this article we will explore the Ayurvedic approach to addressing this imbalance. Measurement of PTSD by Various Sciences At present there are no definite means to measure the degree of damage caused by PTSD. However, there are different ways to measure PTSD, such as interviews, self-report measures, and personality inventories. One of the most common self-report measures is the PCL-5, which is a 20-item questionnaire that matches the DSM-5 criteria for PTSD1. It can help screen for PTSD and monitor its severity over time2. Thus, the damage brought on by traumatic memories and pressure on human psychology is hard to assess with precision. However, per science of Ayurveda, the mental health is an integral and essential part of health, and the capacity to deal with anxiety is the cornerstone of psychological well-being. Ayurvedic Science Perspectives and Treatment of PTSD PTSD from Ayurveda Perspective Ayurveda science is based on the principles that human body is made of five elements: Earth, water, fire, air and ether. Every individual is born with a unique equilibrium of three constitutions that are called as Vata, Pitta, and Kapha. These constitutions have the following elemental compositions: Vata comprises of Air + Ether Pitta comprises of Fire + Water Kapha comprises of Earth+ Water Vata, Pitta and Kapha occur in various percentages in every human body which decides one’s Prakriti (unique psychosomatic constitution). Any imbalance (dosha) of the three constituents will cause physical imbalances in the human body and, if not treated, will precipitate in disturbed mental state and causing imbalances of the three Manogunas (guna means 'virtue' as well as ‘Quality). This disturbances of Manogunas will dictate/ influence the psychological form of an individual subjected to change over time. Per science of Ayurveda there are following three principal qualities of the brain (manogunas/gunas of mind): Sattva – clarity Rajas – arrogance Tamas – inertia Rajas and Tamas are considered as brain vitiators (Manodoshas: Mano-Mind; Dosha-imbalance). The imbalance of these Manodoshas affects the brain and contributes to mental imbalance. This imbalance of mind is further worsened by the improper diet, faulty lifestyle, work stressors, and anxiety. Manas (human being) has subtle and minute specific locations that carry sensory and thoughts energy and are crucial in maintaining a balanced frame of mind. An interplay of Doshas, psychological condition, and Gunas (qualities) results in subtle brain abnormalities/diseases. These ailments ultimately lead to imbalance of Manovaha Srota (Srotas are the channels for the purpose of secretion, conduction and transportation of body constituents 1 ) that results in the interruption or blocking of energy flowing channels of subtle thoughts. In this dynamic, the way Hridaya (heart) interacts together with sensory pathways, is thought of as the origin of the brain’s energy channels. This significance within Ayurvedic science clearly highlights that unfortunate encounters leading to negative emotions contribute to the derangement of psychological media, causing emotional imbalances. Mana does mainly functions of emotional, intellectual activities. All these are related to brain functions. In general, the functions of mana comprise- Chintya means thinking, Vicharya means analysis, Uhya means speculation, Dhyeya means aim/goal as they all impac the Sankalpa means decision making powers of a person 2 . There are no measuring tools to either detect, map or quantify these functions in western medicine, while there are the prime focus of attention in Ayurvedic practice when a person is presented with PTSD. To complement or even replace Western practices to treat PTSD, Ayurvedic practitioner looks at the mental state (imbalance of Vata). In any situation be it physical (accidents, physical injuries etc.) or emotional (witnessing or experiencing above cited symptoms/ Situations) Vata element of a person’s constitution is vitiated. In ayurvedic interpretation, there is imbalance of Air and Ether elements in the body that primarily would adversely influence the Manodasha (mental state) of a person due to vitiation/ adverse effects on the Manogunas. Vata being a highly dynamic state due the physical properties of Air (always moving) and Ether (spaciousness). This in general would cause worry, insomnia, pain (both phantom and real), fear etc. This expansive nature of Vata imbalance, would affect the tow other constitutions of the human body- the Pitta and Kapha, there by causing a tremendous effect on the general functioning (both Physical and Mental) of the subject. The person will behave differently depending on the degree of imbalance of Pitta or Kapha or both. These symptoms are manifested as extreme rage, anger, bouts of hogh emotions followed by low emotions and even depression, lack of appetite of too much of eating of unhealth foods, indulgence in narcotics, physical abuse etc. few to name. PTSD Treatments Western Medicine Options: There are few options available that include Psychotherapy and use of antidepressants. Other options used in the Western approaches are to lessen anxiety, treat physical agitation, nightmares and sleep disorders. Some alternative approaches used are acupuncture and animal assisted therapies via adoption of pets etc. One interesting fact has emerged through data collection and research work is that women are more fragile to PTSD that is could be precipitated during by post-partum periods. In general, a person with weak immune system/ immunocompromised state is more susceptible to PTSD. Brain activity related to associated learning/adaptive responses ny an individual will dictate the severity of the PTSD. This would explain that some PTSD sufferers have a profound response to PTSD and other have little or no visual responses. A prominent treatment involves Psychodrama, where these is enactment of a dramatic situation involvement of role-plating techniques. One study has highlighted trauma focused psychodramas an effective treatment for treating PTSD. Also, the treatment time to address PTSD is critical to an early recovery from PTSD. However, despite all these ways of treatment, the PTSD recovery could be temporary and the person, if not regularly following the treatments will fall back and even deeper in to the PTSD state. Ayurvedic approaches to supplement the western PTSD treatments is an effective tool to provide a long-term solution to PTSD. Also, if the person follows these principles of Ayurvedic practices on a regular basis the person may totally recover from PTSD and lead a normal and satisfactory life. Ayurveda Options: There is no term as PTSD in Ayurveda. However, based on the symptoms, especially subliminal, all the symptoms of PTSD has been observed and documented in various scriptures of Ayurveda. These are cumulatively put under the broader umbrella of Vata imbalance, e.g., post partum state of women- some have very severe effects and other have less sever or none; chronic diseases; post traumatic effects-separation from loved ones due to death. Long journey, break up in relationships, abuses etc. The vata vitiation affects the Mannovaha srota that will impact subtle Mansik dosas like imbalance of Satva, Rajas and Tamas elements of mind. Mana which is known as mind is very well described in ayurveda. Ayurvedic scholars have mentioned that heart can be considered as place of mana. But functions of mana or mind are related to central nervous system. After availability of lots of ayurveda research papers and case studies, now modern science says that the mind and brain are connected. Mind is a set of cognitive faculties including consciousness, perception, thinking, judgement, language and memory. So, the place of mana can be both mind and heart. These facts now further substantiate that the ayurvedic treatments to correct Vata would be vital to ameliorate the symptoms of PTSD and can potentially be a long-term remedy to treat PTSD. Details of vata Imbalance The human body contains the vata qualities- mental, emotional, and physical state all the time. Various disturbances/ stimuli- be it outside or inside causes imbalances that could make them overly dominant. Too much dry, cool, light, rough, mobile, subtle, and airy qualities can provoke symptoms. These stimuli can cause anxiety, restlessness, insomnia, spacing out, and uncontrolled proliferation of thoughts. A vata imbalance is known to affects major systems of the body including the nervous system as well as the digestive system beside other disturbances in the physiology of a human being. These vata imbalances are cause imbalances and functioning of the pitta dosha and kapha dosha. You can learn to prevent excess vata and come out of such imbalances. Ayurveda’s belief is that "like increases like" forms the basis of how doshic imbalances work. Whatever qualities you bring into your life will increase the dosha that has them. In vata’s case, these are dry, light, cool, rough, subtle, and mobile qualities. Continuing to expose yourself to vata qualities will increase vata dosha within you. It will impact your mind, body, and emotions. Symptoms of vata imbalance . Physical: Constipation Gas formation or distension in the abdomen Dehydration Rough, dry skin General body pain and aching Astringent taste lingering in the mouth Weakness, fatigue, & low vitality Sleep disturbance or insomnia Tremors and twitches Dizziness or spacing out Sensitivity to cold and always need to stay warm Behavioural: Irrationality, anxiety, nervousness, agitation, & impatience Desire to run away Confusion, fearfulness & shakiness Feeling ungrounded Excessive movement and/or speech Depression Effects of vata imbalance (as the symptoms settle in, they become harder to change. Mild or severe vata imbalance can cause the following effects): Weakening muscles Joint pains and stiffness Headache Retention Constipation Weight loss Cramps Convulsions, tremors, paralytic attacks Colic Dryness, scaling Phobias Ayurveda Remedies to treat Vata Imbalances: When you start to notice any of the above symptoms and effects, you can start to adjust your eating. You can make other choices to take on other qualities that will cure your vata imbalance. Focus on warm, cooked, moist Vata reducing foods. Add warm spices to your foods such as cinnamon, ginger, cardamom, and small amounts of black pepper. Do Abhyanga daily with warm sesame oil. This is an incredibly balancing and soothing daily practice for Vata dosha. Administer regular body and head massages including Shirodhara. Take regular steam baths. Practice mild purification procedures like basti or vamana. Meditate on a consistent schedule, for stability and calmness of mind. Various Ayurvedic herbs like turmeric, ashwagandha and shatavari will help balance vata. Addition of these practices/ procedures to the existing medical remedies will help ameliorate the PTSD symptoms in most patients. A regular use of such practices along with healthy lifestyle will help the PTSD sufferers lead a healthy, happy and fulfilling life.